Follow Me
Pin It!
This form does not yet contain any fields.
    Powered by Squarespace

    A subteltie for gaming

    The Henrician-era subtlety I entered into Artemisia’s Kingdom Arts and Sciences competition, 2006.

    The subtlety was created from recipes found in Curye on Inglisch, a collection of 14th and 15th century cookery books. I traced the developemtn of certain items– marchpane, sugar plate, candied peels, and candied spices– through Gervase Markham’s The English Housewife (1615). For the final recipes, I used Peter Brears’ excellent work, All the King’s Cooks: The Tudor Kitchens of King Henry VII at Hampton Court Palace.

    The full entry consists of sugar plate playing cards painted with vegetable paints; orange peel suckets; confits made with peppercorns, caraway, and fennel; and painted marchpane dice. The design on the cards was taken from a deck of 16th century cards, and I used a real die to place the pips on the marchpane.





    Take and make a crust in a trap & take cruddes and wryng out þe wheyze and drawe hem þurgh a straynour and put hit in þe crust. Do þerto sugar the þridde part, & somdel whyte of ayren, & shake þerin blomes of elren; & bake it vp with eurose, & messe it forth.

    Hieatt, Constance B. and Sharon Butler. Curye on Inglish: English Culinary Manuscripts of the Fourteenth-Century (Including the Forme of Cury). New York: for The Early English Text Society by the Oxford University Press, 1985.



    * 1 nine-inch pie shell
    * 2 Tbs. heavy cream
    * 2 Tbs. dried elderflowers
    * 3/4 lb. cottage cheese
    * 3/4 lb. ricotta cheese
    * 3 eggs
    * ¼ lb. butter
    * 1/3 cup sugar
    * ¼ tsp. cloves
    * ¼ tsp. mace
    * 1 Tbs. rosewater (optional)

    Combine all ingredients and blend thoroughly. (A food processor or immersion blender will do the job nicely.) Pour mixture into pie shell. Bake at 350° F for 45 minutes to an hour, or until filling has set and the crust is a golden brown. Let cool and serve.


    I made a few changes to the recipe printed above. There are neither elderflowers nor rosewater in my version; I wanted something spicier. Instead of the cloves and mace, I used 2 tsps of Chinese Five Spice powder. This gave me something with a bit more bite, as well as creating a pleasant aroma.

    The crumble topping is actually toasted almonds. I have a large quantity of ground almonds from making the almond milk for the Bruet Saracenes. I hate to waste, so while the pies were baking I spread the ground damp almonds on a sheet and placed them on the top rack of the oven.

    Also, the recipe given makes two nine inch pies.


    Soap for the Hands

    Original recipe:

    Jabón para las manos Tomad una libra de jabón valenciano rallado y atadla en un paño grueso. Y ponedlo en una caldera de agua hirviendo, y cueza allí­ hasta tanto que se pare azul. Y desque cocido, tomad una escudilla de ello, y otra de miel, y otra de hiel de vaca, y media de zumo de lirio, y una escudilla de vinagre. Y ponedlo todo junto en una olla a cocer, y cueza hasta tanto que esté espeso, trayéndolo siempre a una mano. Y si quisiéredes hacerlo peloticas lo dejaréis cocer hasta que se pare duro.

    Manual de mujeres, #36



    Soap for the hands Take a pound of grated Valencian soap and bind in a thick cloth. And put it in a pot of boiling water, and cook it there until it’s turned blue. And while it is cooking, take an escudilla of it, and another of honey, and another of cow’s bile, and half the juice of a lily, and an escudilla of vinegar. And put it all together in a cook-pot, and cook it until it is thick, always stirring it. And if you want to make them into little balls, let it cook until it is hard.

    First redaction:

    1 lb grated Castile soap (see recipe in appendix)

    16 oz. honey

    16 oz. cow bile

    16 oz. vinegar

    2 oz. lily oil

    Tie the grated soap into a cloth and boil it in water until completely melted (the water will develop a bluish cast, like milk, rather than "turning blue". Add the other ingredients and stir until the mixture thickens, then pour into a mold or shape into balls. Let dry for 1 week.

    Grated soap 


    Unfortunately, my attempts to recreate the recipe as translated from the original source did not produce a usable soap. My first attempt resulted in a sticky mass that had to be pried out of the pot; I threw this batch away. For my second attempt, I reduced the additives by half. This mixture seemed more promising; however, the addition of the vinegar caused the mixture to rice. Ricing occurs when the fat solids separate from the oils and liquids in the soap and create a lightweight waxy mass. All attempts to rebatch this attempt failed.

    Boiling soap in cloth

    Finally, I turned to a soapmaking reference book and developed the following method that I believe comes close to replicating the intended product.

    Second Redaction:

    1 lb. grated Castile soap

    8 oz. honey

    2 oz. cow bile

    8 oz. vinegar

    2 tsp. bitter orange oil

    Melt the soap in a double boiler over medium heat. Just before pouring into molds, add other ingredients and stir well to blend.

    After molding, let set for 24 hours. Scoop the soft soap from the mold and roll into balls. Allow to dry for 3-5 days.


    Castile soap

    12 oz lye

    36 oz water

    36 oz non-virgin olive oil

    Pour water into a dedicated pitcher with a tightly-sealing lid. Measuring carefully and working slowly in a room with adequate ventilation, pour the lye crystals into the water. Stir with a wooden spoon until the lye is dissolved. Let the lye cool to between 100 and 120 degrees Fahrenheit.

    While the lye is cooling, add the olive oil to a stainless steel cookpan and heat to 120 degrees. Balance the cooling lye and the heating oil until both are between 100F and 120F.

    Slowly pour the lye into the oil, stirring constantly. Once the two are combined, either stir the mixture for 20 minutes to one hour by hand, or use a stick blender set on low. The mixture should be stirred until a spoon drawn across the surface leaves visible trails.

    Pour the mixture into a mold, cover, wrap in a towel, and set aside in a warm spot for 48 hours. After the soap is set, turn it out of the mold and cut it into bars. Set the bars out to air for 2-3 weeks.

    Castile soap

    Valencian soap:

    Valencian soap probably refers to Castile soap, a hard white olive oil soap widely manufactured in the kingdom of Castile and exported through Europe. In 1423, the city of Seville was granted a royal license for a monopoly on the production of soap; while Seville and Castile were not the only locations of soap factories, it is likely that the soap produced by other royal factories was the same (Carmona and Donoso, 3).

    Cow bile:

    Ox gall liquid

    Bile acts to some extent as a detergent, helping to emulsify fats (increasing surface area to help enzyme action), and thus aids in their absorption in the small intestine. In the intestines, bile salts combine with phospholipids to break down fat globules in the process of emulsification by associating its hydrophobic side with lipids and the hydrophilic side with water. Emulsified droplets then are organized into many micelles which increases absorption. Since bile increases the absorption of fats, it is an important part of the absorption of the fat-soluble vitamins D, E, K and A.

    Taurocholic acid, known also as cholaic acid, cholyltaurine, or acidum cholatauricum, is a deliquescent yellowish crystalline bile acid involved in the emulsification of fats. It occurs as a sodium salt in the bile of mammals. It is a conjugate of cholic acid with taurine. In medical use, it is administered as a cholagogue and choleretic. Hydrolysis of taurocholic acid yields taurine, a nonessential amino acid. For commercial use, taurocholic acid is manufactured from cattle bile, a byproduct of the meat-processing industry.

    Deoxycholic acid, also known as deoxycholate, cholanoic acid, and 3?,12?-dihydroxy-5?-cholanate, is a bile acid. Deoxycholic acid is one of the secondary bile acids, which are metabolic byproducts of intestinal bacteria. The two primary bile acids secreted by the liver are cholic acid and chenodeoxycholic acid. Bacteria metabolize chenodeoxycholic acid into the secondary bile acid lithocholic acid, and they metabolize cholic acid into deoxycholic acid. There are additional secondary bile acids, such as ursodeoxycholic acid. Deoxycholic acid is soluble in alcohol and acetic acid. When pure, it comes in a white to off-white crystalline powder form. In the human body deoxycholic acid is used in the emulsification of fats for the absorption in the intestine.

    Bile from slaughtered animals can be mixed with soap. This mixture, called bile soap, can be applied to textiles a few hours before washing and is a traditional and rather effective method for removing various kinds of tough stains (Olsen interview).


    Bitter orange oil:

     Rose otto and bitter orange oil

    I substituted bitter orange oil– also called Seville orange– for the lily oil due to cost and allergy considerations. Neroli oil is produced from the blossom of the bitter orange tree (Citrus aurantium); it is similar in scent to bergamot. Neroli oil is often used in aromatherapy to relieve tension and anxiety, and to increase circulation ("Bitter orange," 2). Orange blossom oil/water is mentioned in several recipes in the Libre del Coch and the Manual de Mujeres, and therefore is an acceptable period substitution for lily oil.



    Weights and Measures:

    Escudilla: (a small hemispherical cup) Escudilla, “Dish” is used in three ways in the text. First, it refers to a bowl.   Second, it is used as a synonym for “a serving”.  Many of the recipes say, “and this will make x number of escudillas“. Lastly, it is a measurement of volume, much like 19th century recipes call for a “wineglass” or a “teacup” of a certain ingredient.  A recipe for preserved dates in Granado calls for “three pounds of water, or three escudillas” (Granado, 395) which seems to indicate that the escudillas of that time held about 16 fl. oz.  Studies of 15th and 16th century Iberian pottery found at archeological sites show that escudillas varied in size, with rim diameters ranging from 8 cm. to 15 cm. (about 3-3/8 to 6 inches), but 13-14 cm. (about 5-1/4 to 6 inches) seems to have been the most common. A modern bowl in my kitchen, whose shape and proportions are similar to illustrations of medieval escudillas has a rim diameter of 13-1/2 cm. and a capacity of 600 ml. (about 20 fl. oz.) (Nola, Libre del Coch).




    Anonimo. "Jabón para las manos." Manual de mujeres en el cual se contienen muchas y diversas recetas muy buenas. Alicante: Biblioteca Virtual Miguel de Cervantes, 1999. Accessed online February 2009.

     "Bitter Orange." National Center for Complmentary and Alternative Medicine. April 2008. Accessed online February 2009.

    Browning, Marie. Natural Soapmaking. New York: Sterling Pub. Co., 1999.

    Carmona, Salvador and Rafael Donoso. "An institutional approach to the role of cost accounting in regulated markets: the case of the Royal Soap Factory of Seville (1515-1692)." Working paper. Getafe, Spain; Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, 2002.

     Grosso, Alicia. The Everything Soapmaking Book: recipes and techniques for creating colorful and fragrant soaps. Avon, Mass. : Adams Media, 2007.

    Nola, Ruperto de. Libre del Coch, 1529. Trans. Brighid ni Chiarain. Accessed online February 2009. .

    Olsen, Kim. Chemistry instructor. Personal Interview. Episcopal High School; Alexandria, VA, February 20


    Spanish Chocolate


    Chocolate in its modern forms--a highly sweetened bar of candy or ingredient in cakes and cookies-- is not historically accurate for much of Europe during the majority of the scope of SCA time (c. 600-1600 CE). However, a chocolate drink created by the combination of ground roasted cacao beans, sweetened with sugar and flavored with spices, was popular among the royalty and nobility of Spain in the late 16th century. This beverage, based on the xocholatl consumed by the Aztecs, was transported from the Americas to Spain by early conquistadors and settlers, and eventually spread to the rest of Europe. By the mid-seventeeth century, this MesoAmerican concoction was a common item in homes across Europe and the Americas.

    Aztec Chocolate

    Fernandez de Oviedo, a member of Cortes' expedition, wrote extensively of the use of chocolate in Aztec society. He reported that cacao beans and cacao products were used for religious rituals, as currency, as a beverage for the wealthy, a drug, an aphrodisiac, and as a portable food source (de Lemps 385). A paste made from ground cacao beans was combined with different additives such as "chili pepper, achiote, corn, fruit, even hallucinogenic mushrooms" (de Lemps 384).

    Despite some regional differences in the specific preparations of chocolate, the concoction was common to every part of the Aztec Empire. As Marcy Norton explains:

    From Nicaragua to northwest Mexico, there was a fundamental sameness among the modes of consumption, ritual contexts, and symbolic resonances of chocolate. Everywhere, the prevailing cacao concoction was consumed as a beverage, sometimes hot and sometimes cold, mixed with maize or not, and often sweetened with honey and spiced with chili peppers, vanilla, and other fragrant flora. The starting point for all of them was the same. Cacao nibs-- what are commonly called 'beans,' or the seeds inside the pulpy mass of the cacao fruit-- were dried and fermented to increase their "oily and buttery" qualities. They were then toasted until the nibs turned from brown to black and sloughed off their husks, and finally they were ground between two stones (one of which had a fire burning beneath) known as a metate. (A similar process still characterizes chocolate production.) The paste that resulted was perishable and would spoil within a week. If formed into hardened tablets, however, it would last for up to two years. The final beverage was made by dissolving the cacao paste in water and mixing in diverse additions (maize, spices, honey) (671).


    Spain and the New World

    In 1502, Christopher Columbus and his men captured a Mayan canoe at Guanaja Island near Honduras; the cargo included several pounds of cacao beans, which Columbus later described as the "'nuts' which were used as money in New Spain" (Jamieson 271). Seventeen years later, as Cortes launched what would become the conquest of the Aztec Empire, he and his men encountered chocolate for the first time; however, the early impressions noted by explorers and missionary priests were overwhelmingly negative. Girolamo Benzoni, a Milanese adventurer in Nicaragua, found the drink spicy, bitter, and thought it "seemed more a drink for pigs, than a drink for humanity" (Norton 668). Likewise, the Jesuit priest Jose de Acosta insisted that anyone who was not accustomed to the drink "could not have a taste for it," and compared the foamy froth that capped the drink to feces" (Norton 668).

    Despite the beverage's poor initial reception, frequent contact with chocolate throughout the Spanish-held territories led to an increased tolerance for and interest in consuming it. Mission priests were often paid in cacao beans, a Spanish encomendero (the conquistador-turned-Spanish lord who received tribute from Indians) ordered his subjects to prepare a thousand pounds of "ground cacao ready to drink" for his voyage to Spain in 1531, and retinue of Indians brought Prince Philip (the future Philip II) a gift of chocolate in 1544 (Norton 679). Chocolate trickled into Spain, primarily a novelty or luxury item for the royalty and nobility, until late in the 16th century. It was not established in Seville until the early 17th century; however, it was listed in tax records as a regular trade item in the 1590s, indicating that there was a regular and somewhat steady influx of chocolate onto the Iberian Peninsula (Norton 679). The first Spanish work about chocolate was printed in 1624; it is from this work that the recipe I have used is taken.


    Evolution of Chocolate

    Although the drink that the Spanish first encountered tended to be bitter and spicy, importation to Europe and adoption of the drink-- for it was almost universally consumed as a drink until the early 19th century– by Spanish and other European consumers altered the composition significantly. Imitating the Aztec and Mayan habit of sweetening their chocolate with honey, the Spanish added sugar from their vast plantations in Valencia and the Caribbean (Norton 684). The Spanish also "substituted familiar spices: cinnamon, black pepper, anise, rose, and sesame, among others" in place of the native flower spice complex, achiote, and chili peppers (Norton 684).


    The Recipe


    To every 100 Cacaos, you must put two cods of the long red Pepper, of which I have spoken before, and are called, in the Indian Tongue, Chilparlagua; and in stead of those of the Indies, you may take those of Spaine; which are broadest, and least hot. One handfull of Annis-seed Orejuelas, which are otherwise called Vinacaxlidos: and two of the flowers, called Mechasuehil, if the Belly be bound. But in stead of this, in Spaine, we put in sixe Roses of Alexandria beat to Powder: One Cod of Campeche, or Logwood: Two Drams of Cinamon, Almons, and Hasle-Nuts, of each one Dozen: Of white Sugar, halfe a pound: Of Achiote, enough to give it the colour. And if you cannot have those things, which come from the Indies, you may make it with the rest.

    The Cacao, and the other Ingredients must be beaten in a Morter of Stone, or ground upon a broad stone, which the Indians call Metate, and is onely made for that use: But the first thing that is to be done, is to dry the Ingredients, all except the Achiote; with care that they may be beaten to powder, keeping them still in stirring, that they be not burnt, or become blacke; and if they be over-dried, they will be bitter, and lose their vertue. The Cinamon, and the long red Pepper are to be first beaten, with the Annis-seed; and then beate the Cacao, which you must beate by a little and little, till it be all powdred; and sometimes turn it round in the beating, that it may mixe the better: And every one of these Ingredients, must be beaten by it selfe; and then put all the Ingredients into the Vessell, where the Cacao is; which you must stirre together with a spoone, and then take out that Paste, and put it into the Morter, under which you must lay a little fire, after the Confection is made. But you must be very carefull, not to put more fire, than will warme it, that the unctuous part does not dry away. And you must also take care, to put in the Achiote in the beating; that it may the better take the colour. You must Searse all the Ingredients, but onely the Cacao; and if you take the shell from the Cacao, it is the better; and when you shall find it to be well beaten, and incorporated (which you shall know by the shortnesse of it) then with a spoone take up some of the Paste, which will be almost liquid; and so either make it into Tablets; or put it into Boxes, and when it is cold it will be hard. To make the Tablets, you must put a spoonefull of the paste upon a piece of paper, the Indians put it upon the leaf of a Planten-tree; where, being put into the shade, it growes hard; and then bowing the paper, the Tablet falls off, by reason of the fatnesse of the paste. But if you put it into any thing of earth, or wood, it sticks fast, and will nor come off, but with scraping, or breaking.

    There is another way to drinke Chocolate, which is cold; and it takes its name from the principall Ingredient, and is called Cacao; which they use at feasts, to refresh themselves; and it is made after this manner. The Chocolate being dissolved in water with the Molinet, take off the scumme, or crassy part, which riseth in greater quantity, when the Cacao is older, and more putrified. The scumme is laid aside by it selfe in a little dish; and then put sugar into that part, from whence you took the scumme; and powre it from on high into the scumme; and so drinke it cold.

     - Antonio Colmenero, tran. Don Diego de Vades-forte."A Curious Treatise of the Nature and Quality of Chocolate." Published in London in 1640, in Spain before 1631.



    Translation of Original Recipe

    Aztec recipe:

    100 cacao beans

    2 cods long red pepper

    Handful of anise-seed

    2 mecaxo´chitl flowers


    Spanish recipe:

    100 cacao beans

    2 cods long red pepper or Spanish peppers

    6 roses of Alexandria, powdered

    1 cod Campeche

    2 drams cinnamon

    12 almonds

    12 hazelnuts

    .5 lb. white sugar

    Achiote for color

    Grind the cacao beans in a mortar until ground and set it aside in another vessel. Dry all other ingredients except the achiote until they are dried but not burnt. Grind all the ingredients individually and separately until they are a fine powder, turning the mortar at intervals. When these are powdered, then mix these together in the vessel with the ground cacao beans. Stir them together with a spoon, and place into the mortar. Heat the mortar gently and mix the ingredients together. When the mix is well-combined and nearly liquid, take it up with a spoon and make it into tablets, or put it into boxes.

    To make tablets, put a spoonful of the paste onto a piece of paper and let it harden.


    The Redaction

    Aztec recipe, adjusted

    100 cacao beans

    3 tsp. dried cayenne pepper

    Small handful of anise seeds (substitute for mecaxo´chitl flowers)

    1 tsp. black pepper (substitute for xochinacaztli)

    1 tsp. vanilla (additional substitute for xochinacaztli)

    6 tablespoons honey


    Spanish recipe, adjusted

    100 cacao beans

    3 tsp. dried cayenne pepper

    2 tsp. cinnamon

    Small handful of anise seeds

    1 tsp vanilla

    1 tsp black pepper

    12 almonds

    .5 lb white sugar (about 1 cup)

    Achiote to color (about 2 tbsp)

    I chose to make one batch of chocolate; one following as closely as possible the adapted Spanish recipe. I purchased two pounds of raw organic Mexican cacao beans, a pound of raw organic Spanish almonds, and a backup pound of roasted organic cocoa nibs.


    Nuts and nibs

    I roasted the cacao beans, 100 at a time, on a cookie sheet in a 300 degree oven for 20 minutes per batch (this is the temperature and roasting duration recommended by the retailer). After a 20 minute roast and 10 minutes of cooling time, the hulls of the beans split open are were easily removed. I hulled the beans and discarded any that had burned or that did not split.


    Nuts and nibs

    I repeated the process with the almonds, although the skins of the almonds remained intact after roasting and cooling.

    In the interests of time, I used a food chopper to mince each ingredient, and used a coffee grinder to grind each ingredient to a fine powder. As indicated in the original recipe, I ground each ingredient separate from all the others and then combined them in one bowl. I also ground the roasted almonds to a fine meal.

    Ground ingredients

    In a medium pot, I heated the mixture over low heat until the ingredients melted and became a thick semi-liquid paste, about the consistency of unset fudge. Each batch ultimately melted at a different rate and temperature, which indicates that close observation is necessary when preparing the chocolate.



    I altered my initial redaction to include more ingredients. I believe that I misread Colmenero's notation that ". . . in stead of this [mecaxo´chitl flowers], in Spaine, we put in sixe Roses of Alexandria beat to Powder. . . " At first reading, it seemed that Colmenero intended to omit all ingredients after the flowers; however, several more readings led me to believe that the only ingredient from the original Aztec recipe to be omitted was the flowers; these were to be substituted with Rose of Alexandria.



     I poured the mixture onto a sheet lined with parchment paper and let it set until cold. The resulting slab was then broken into pieces and packed into a box.


    Appendix of Additives

    Achiote: (Engl. annatto, Lat. Bixa orellana) used to tint the chocolate beverage red; the seeds "imparted a slightly musky flavor (sometimes compared to paprika and saffron)" (Norton 672).


    Anise: (Pimpinella anisum)

    Black pepper: (Piper nigrum)

    Campeche: (Engl. Logwood, Lat. Haematoxylum campechianum) A tree in the legume family, native to Central America, used for stains in textiles and paper. Logwood was probably included in the recipe to provide the reddish color previously created by the addition of achiote.

     Cinnamon:(Cinnamomum verum)

    "Dried ground flowers":

    1. xochinacaztli (also known as gueynacaztle ), probably Cymbopetalum penduliflorm, a tree of the custard-apple family that grows in Veracruz, Oaxaca, and Chiapas. Norton describes the taste as "akin to that of black pepper with a hint of resinous bitterness, and compared to nutmeg, allspice, and cinnamon" (Norton 672).
    2. mecaxo´chitl (probably Piper sanctum and related to black pepper) with a spicy, floral edge reminiscent of anise (Norton 672).
    3. tlixochitl (Vanilla planifolia). This flower spice constellation had an ancient lineage, in evidence in Mayan cosmological and sacred texts of the Popul Vuh (Norton 672)

     'Long red pepper': Probably a type of chili pepper rather than the Indonesian long pepper (Piper longum) that was common in Europe during the 16th century. Given Colmenero's description of the item and the types of chili native to Central America, cayenne pepper (Capsicum annuum) seems mostly likely.

     Sugar: In the first half of the 15th century, the Valencia region of Spain was widely known for its sugar refineries; the region exported sugar to the rest of Europe as well as providing the sweetener to wealthy Spanish patrons (de Lemps 384). The Portuguese introduced sugar can from Sicily to the island of Madeira during the same period; eventually, the demand for Portuguese sugar outstripped the production abilities of both Madeira and Valencia, so new areas were sought for cultivation. This led to the Spanish conquest and colonization of the Canary Islands, and the Portuguese settlement of Sao Tome (de Lemps 384). The demand for sugar steadily increased, and the early cultivation projects of Spanish settlers in places such as Hispaniola, Mexico, and Spanish America tended to be sugar cane. This increased sugar consumption has been linked to the discovery of chocolate, coffee, and tea (de Lemps 384).

    Vanilla: (Sp. Vainilla, Lat. Vanilla planifolia) Native to Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean. Despite the presence of vanilla in Colmenero's recipe, vanilla was not commonly used until the middle of the 19th century (Medina 44).



    Appendix of Measurements

    Cod: Probably a single pod, equivalent to about 1 tsp. dried and ground.

    Dram: 1/8 of a fluid ounce or 1 teaspoon (British, obscure)



     Colmenero de Ledesma, Antonio. "Chocolate: or, an Indian Drinke." Transl. James Wadsworth. Published in London in 1652, in Spain before 1631. Archived online at .

     —. "A Curious Treatise of the Nature and Quality of Chocolate." Transl. Don Diego de Vades-forte. Published in London in 1640, in Spain before 1631.

     Huetz de Lemps, Alain. "Colonial beverages and the consumption of sugar." Food: A Culinary History. Ed. Jean-Louis Flandrin. Columbia University Press: New York, 1999.

     Flandrin, Jean-Louis. "The Early Modern Period." Food: A Culinary History. Ed. Jean-Louis Flandrin. Columbia University Press: New York, 1999.

     Jamieson, Ross W. "The essence of commodification: caffeine dependencies in the Early Modern world." Journal of Social History. 35:2, 2001. Archived online at . Last accessed 10/09/08.

     Medina, F. Xavier. Food Culture in Spain. Greenwood Press: Westport CN, 2005.

     Norton, Marcy. "Tasting empire: chocolate and the European internalization of Mesoamerican aesthetics." American Historical Review. June 2006.

     O'Connor, Sarah. "Tablets of Drinking Chocolate in the Spanish Style." Stefan's Florilegium. Archived online 5 July 2008 at http:// beverages/?drink-choc-sp-art.html. Accessed 20 Oct. 2008.